The Right Legal Advice When You Need It the Most

Photo of the legal team at Smith Family Law APC

Why should some couples in San Diego resolve their divorce with a settlement?

by | Oct 29, 2025 | Child Support

San Diego, CA – A recent celebrity divorce case highlights some of the reasons why a divorce attorney can be beneficial during settlement negotiations.

Celebrity couple settles their divorce case

Quinta Brunson, the acclaimed creator and star of Abbott Elementary, and her estranged husband, Kevin Jay Anik, have reached a divorce settlement, as reported by TMZ on September 26, 2025 [1]. Brunson filed documents indicating that the couple has a written agreement on property division, with the next step being a judge’s approval to finalize the divorce. The couple, married in October 2021, cited “irreconcilable differences” in court documents filed in March, noting a postnuptial agreement governing their assets. Both parties requested to cover their own legal fees.

Brunson, a Philadelphia native, has consistently guarded her personal life, with many fans unaware of her marriage until her 2022 Emmy acceptance speech. In a June interview with Bustle, she expressed frustration over the public’s access to personal details, emphasizing her desire for privacy. “Even if you don’t give a lot, people want whatever they can get,” she said, addressing misconceptions that public figures willingly share personal milestones. Brunson clarified that she never publicly announced her divorce, lamenting how public records expose private matters like buying a house or major life changes. “I hate all of it,” she stated.

Despite her personal challenges, Brunson remains focused on her career. At 35, she is eager to leverage Abbott Elementary’s success to support other creators’ projects, as she shared in the same Bustle interview. Her professional achievements, including an Emmy win, highlight her rising influence in the entertainment industry. Brunson’s ability to navigate personal transitions while maintaining a thriving career underscores her resilience and commitment to her craft, as she continues to prioritize privacy amid public scrutiny.

What is the purpose of a divorce settlement in California?

In California, a couple may agree to a divorce settlement for various reasons, driven by legal, financial, emotional, and practical considerations. A divorce settlement, often referred to as a marital settlement agreement, is a legally binding contract that outlines how a couple will divide assets, debts, and responsibilities, and may include provisions for spousal support, child custody, and visitation. Opting for a settlement rather than a contested divorce offers several advantages, particularly in California’s community property state framework, where assets and debts acquired during marriage are typically split equally. Below are key reasons why a couple might choose this path.

First, a divorce settlement provides control over the outcome. California courts follow strict community property laws, meaning a judge will divide marital assets and debts 50/50 unless a valid agreement, like a prenuptial or postnuptial contract, exists. By negotiating a settlement, couples can customize the division to suit their unique needs. For instance, one spouse might keep a family home in exchange for relinquishing other assets, avoiding a rigid court-imposed split. This flexibility allows couples to prioritize financial or sentimental priorities, such as retaining a business or ensuring one spouse’s financial stability.

Second, settlements are often faster and less costly than litigation. California’s court system can be time-consuming, with contested divorces taking months or even years, especially in complex cases involving significant assets or custody disputes. Legal fees can escalate quickly, draining resources. A settlement, reached through negotiation or mediation, reduces attorney fees and court costs, allowing couples to resolve matters efficiently. For example, mediation in California, a popular alternative, involves a neutral third party helping couples reach a mutually acceptable agreement, often in a matter of weeks.

Third, privacy is a significant motivator. As seen in high-profile cases like that of Quinta Brunson and Kevin Anik, public figures often prefer settlements to keep personal details out of court records, which are typically public. Brunson, in a 2025 Bustle interview, expressed frustration over public access to private matters like divorce filings. A settlement minimizes court involvement, reducing the likelihood of sensitive financial or personal information becoming public. This is particularly appealing for couples valuing discretion, whether due to fame or personal preference.

Fourth, settlements reduce emotional strain. Divorce litigation can be adversarial, pitting spouses against each other in court battles that exacerbate conflict. This is especially challenging when children are involved, as prolonged disputes can harm co-parenting relationships. A settlement fosters collaboration, allowing couples to part ways amicably. In California, where courts prioritize the best interests of children in custody decisions, a settlement lets parents craft tailored custody and support plans, ensuring stability for their children without a judge’s intervention.

Fifth, certainty and finality drive settlement decisions. Contested divorces carry the risk of unpredictable judicial rulings, whereas a settlement guarantees agreed-upon terms, assuming a judge approves them as fair. This is critical in California, where complex financial portfolios or high-value assets, like real estate in expensive markets, can complicate court rulings. A settlement provides peace of mind, allowing both parties to move forward without lingering legal battles.

Finally, cultural and social factors may encourage settlements. California’s progressive legal environment supports alternative dispute resolution methods like mediation and collaborative divorce, reflecting a broader trend toward less confrontational separations. Couples may also choose settlements to preserve mutual respect or align with personal values, especially when both parties acknowledge irreconcilable differences, as cited in Brunson and Anik’s case.

In summary, couples in California opt for divorce settlements to maintain control, save time and money, protect privacy, reduce emotional toll, ensure certainty, and align with cooperative legal trends. By negotiating terms, couples can navigate divorce with greater autonomy and dignity, tailored to their unique circumstances.

Smith Family Law Staff

Family attorneys are available in the San Diego area

Smith Family Law is available to help local clients with issues such as divorces, child custody,

alimony, domestic violence, and settlements.

Firm contact info: 

Smith Family Law

225 Broadway, Suite 2220, San Diego, CA 92101

619-431-3131

https://www.smithfamilylaw.com/

 

Sources:

  1. https://www.vibe.com/news/entertainment/quinta-brunson-kevin-anik-finalize-divorce-1235127935/